I finally had a chance to see one of these in person recently and they are pretty nice. They did a decent job of replicating the old time feel, not perfect, but probably an 8 out of 10 for the feel. I think it is reasonable to assume that somebody who doesn't handle a lot of vintage cards could mistake these for legitimate vintage cards. These have been pretty good sellers on eBay too. The Cubs cards I have noticed have typically ended between $50-$100.
There is no full checklist published for these (at least that I am aware of), but I have tried to give a summary below of each of the sets that Helmar has done in this style and listed the Cubs I am aware of with some photos. The list of Cubs is likely not complete, I'll add more to this post as I see new ones. These don't qualify for my master checklist as they are hand made. And while I wouldn't pay the current prices for one of them, if I could get an Anson or an Evers for $20 at some point, I would consider it.
R319 - These are done in the style of 1933 Goudey (R319 is the Standard Catalog designation for the 1933 Goudey set). They measure 2-3/8" x 2-7/8". Reportedly 180 cards in the set, plus some 'high numbers'.
#30 Dolph Camilli
#41 Ernie Banks
#50 Mordecai Brown
#59 Johnny Evers
#60 Hack Wilson
#71 Cap Anson
#105 Joe Tinker
#141 Gabby Hartnett
#181 Charlie Grimm
#30 Dolph Camilli
#41 Ernie Banks
#50 Mordecai Brown
#59 Johnny Evers
#60 Hack Wilson
#71 Cap Anson
#105 Joe Tinker
#141 Gabby Hartnett
#181 Charlie Grimm
E145 - These are done in the style of the 1914-15 Cracker Jack cards (E145 is the Standard Catalog designation for that set). They measure 2-1/4" x 3".
#27 Jimmy Archer
Imperial Cabinets - These are large cabinet sized cards that measure 8.25" x 11". Haven't seen any Cubs to date in this set.
Heroes of the Polo Grounds - These measure 4-5/8" x 6" and feature New York Giants players. Reportedly 66 cards in the set. No Cubs expected in this set.
Trolley Card Series - These measure 2.4" x 5".
Frank Chance
Mordecai Brown
6-Up Team Composites - These are six player composites that measure 4.5" x 6". Reportedly 55 cards in the set.
- Frank Schulte, Jack Pfeister, Harry Steinfeldt, Joe Tinker, Orval Overall, and Rube Kroh
- Frank Sculte, Ed Reulbach, Jimmy Sheckard, Orval Overall, Joe Tinker, and Mordecai Brown
- Heinie Zimmerman, Johnny Evers, Pat Moran, Joe Tinker, Orval Overall, and Jack Pfeister
- Tom Needham, Del Howard, Johnny Kling, Jeff Pfeffer, Carl Lundgren, and Solly Hofman (not pictured)
No comments:
Post a Comment